Large herbivores may buffer effect of climate change on plant communities

By Katrina Voss
February 25, 2013

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- Whether existing ecological communities can persist intact as temperatures rise may depend as much on biological interactions that shape communities themselves as on the effects of climate change, according to a Penn State researcher.

Eric Post, professor of biology, simulated climate change and integrated the effects of large, plant-eating mammals in a 10-year Arctic field experiment. The results of the research suggest that Arctic plant communities are more likely to resist destabilization by climate change if populations of caribou, musk ox and other large herbivores remain intact.

"The study demonstrates that grazing by these large herbivores maintains plant species diversity, while warming reduces it," Post said. "Plant communities with lower diversity display a greater tendency toward instability under warming, a pre-cursor to the loss of such communities."

Post’s study was recently published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B.

Climate-change research in the 1980s and 1990s was focused primarily on how fluctuations in such factors as temperature, precipitation and nutrient availability directly affected plant communities, noted Post.

"That research was important and enlightening, but what it did not emphasize were the indirect effects of climate change -- how interactions among species may shape the responses of those species to warmer temperatures," he said. "If the planet continues to warm by 1.5 to 3.0 degrees Celsius over the next century, as the models predict, we need to know not only what the warming will do to plants and animals directly, but also how species' interactions may influence those effects of warming."

Post began the study in a remote, low-Arctic plant community near Kangerlussuaq, Greenland, in 2002. To simulate the effects of the 1.5-to-3.0-degrees-Celsius warming that is predicted to occur over the next century, he erected special warming chambers -- cone-shaped hollow structures that create a greenhouse effect. Some areas on which those warming chambers were placed were left open to grazing by caribou and musk ox, two ecologically important large herbivores in the Arctic. Separate 800-square-meter areas that also received warming chambers were fenced off to exclude the animals.

In this way, Post created two very different environments: one in which plants and herbivores continued to live together as the temperatures climbed within the warming chambers; the other in which the animals were not present and the plants were left ungrazed.

"The study tested a classic ecological hypothesis, but with a new angle," Post said. "Ecologists have argued for decades over whether species-rich plant communities are more stable, and hence persistent in the face of environmental disturbance, than species-poor communities. This study added a layer of complexity by asking whether large herbivores contribute to the diversity-stability relationship in a climate-change context."

After 10 years of careful observation, Post found that the grazed and ungrazed sections of land fared differently in their responses to warmer temperatures.

"This study confirmed that caribou and musk ox act as a buffer against the degradative effects of warming on plant species diversity," Post said. He found that shrubs such as willow and birch became the dominant plants in response to warming where the herbivorous animals were excluded from the ecosystem.

"When these shrubs expand in the plant community, they tend to shade their neighbors, and the build-up of leaf litter around the shrubs tends to cool the soil surface, reducing the availability of soil nutrients for other plants," Post said. "As a result, shrubs can quickly out-compete other plants and reduce species diversity in the process. On the other hand, in those areas where caribou and musk ox were able to graze freely, shrub responses to warming were muted, and species diversity within the plant community was maintained."

"What this experiment suggests is that factors that threaten the persistence of large herbivores may threaten the plant communities they exist in, as well. Conservation of these herbivores in the rapidly changing Arctic will require careful mediation of interacting stressors such as human exploitation, mineral extraction, and the direct effects of climate change," Post said.

Post said that the next step in his research will be to study the contribution of plant diversity to long-term stability of carbon dynamics in the atmosphere and in the soil.

The research was funded by the National Geographic Society and the National Science Foundation.

  • An adult male caribou, photographed in Greenland

(Media Contacts)

Last Updated February 11, 2020